This is the difference between you and I. You are extremely detail focused. I'm more big picture.
I don't think there's wrong or right here. Just different shades of mind fuckededness
.
I thought I was the one taking the holistic approach
I'm looking at more than just the outline of abs popping thru some adipose as a signal to stop cutting. But i'm done with this discussion/debate, it's utterly pointless so i'm bowing out. No ones mind will be change today or ever, you gotta learn the hard way and then it's always obvious that the best advice was the one we didn't want to contemplate. Been there done that, even as recently as 2 months ago ("i see my abs, i'll be 10% by 80kg fo sho" ...).
i don't think it's pointless, although sometimes debating with you can be frustrating because you're so committed to your own idiosyncratic interpretation of things. you're a bit like avishek used to be with his batshit insane exercises, but for nutrition/diet. and that guy was OUT THERE on diet, too, back in the day. he went all raw foods for a while.
what you do works for you pretty well, although you do yo-yo kind of a lot weight-wise. so keep doing your thing, but please don't get frustrated when other people argue against the way you interpret nutrition and diet information. it's not even that you're wrong necessarily -- i don't think anyone on here, except t0ddday during his drop-ins, is enough of an expert to say that with real backed-up confidence; we're all just interpreting what we read, too -- just that the way you read things and claim they should be applied is convoluted and strange and the rest of us just seem to process things a bit more straightforwardly and don't take things to such extremes.