193
« on: November 16, 2010, 04:23:18 pm »
Again, im not at the position to say one is "better" than the other...just like one could argue a person could get GREAT results all doing these exercises, even though like u stated and its true the movements and muscles loaded are totally different
-high bar full squat
-low bar full squat power lifting style(no knee travel)
-low bar power style(rippltoe)
-Bulgarian Split Squats
-Heavy Lunges
- box squat wide
- box squat regular
- front squats
ETC
My view is strength is strength(unless its your sport). If your getting stronger your getting stronger, who to say if you display it in the box squat, or the low bar squat, or the freaking BSS that your going to be better off? Now this is taking into account that its an exercise thats not detrimental to your safety or performance and will give desired you desired adaptations(muscle mass,not kill your CNS every workout just to load it(extra high squats,leg press etc)
In terms of your statement about power snatches, I again disagree with you. They are great explosive strength exercises, but although much harder in degree of difficulty technique wise, I do not believe any superior to other explosive strength means(jump squats, paused jumps, from box jumps whatever)
Again, this is my view on the matter and trying to convince me otherwise and that I "have" to squat till my ass touches my calves or whatever will not counter the view that i have witnessed and read about(James Smith a ton) that strength is general work and should be viewed as such.
adarq cant squat hardly a lot of weight at all. I bet he cant even bulgrain or lunge a lot, or box squat a lot. He still damn strong. My little brother squats wide low bar and defintely no where near full and has tremendous lower body strength which helped him make huge strides in speed and explosiveness while also becoming a state champ and also working himself basically into being a division one football recruit..I have seen the results personally of James Smith and how he coaches his guys, although he would not advise my forward knee travel technique at all.
But I degrees, your statement on form holds true 100% accurate. Whatever general strength exercise you use, being orthopedically sound is THE most important issue, period. And if my form is setting me up for injury, obviously this is something I must alter.
From a squat perspective, I always view the following in terms of safety
1) Low back rounding - Mine I believe is fine, maybe its because im quite parallel or at parallel though
2) Knee travel- Again I think its natural, BUT your right when mine is extreme. My ass should be back farther.
Solution- I am going to watch ripptoes videos tonight and tomorrow, place the bar lower, although not ridiculously low,and hopefully this allows me to get ass back more and knees less. Ill try to tape. Appreciate your input
Also, Im not trying to start an argument or be a jerk and I appreciate your input.