What if we go the other way around? Say, with an easier exercise like the leg press vs the squat? The leg press doesn't require any stabilization that you require in the squat just as the BSS or lunge requires less stabilization vs the shrimp.
So far, less need for stabilization was actually better.
well i mentioned specificity, that solves this argument immediately... leg press has far less specificity than squat, so regardless of how simple an exercise is, to get the most out of your improvements in max strength, the exercise needs to allow you to move the most load possible in a movement pattern most similar to the ones you are trying to improve.. now someone is going to say this "well why not just use jump squats instead of squat"... the key is "moving the most load possible", so jump squat is out of the conversation.. jump squat would be relevant to an explosive strength conversation.. a better argument would be jump squat vs ballistic leg press to improve explosive strength, etc..
we've had these conversations before raptor, and it always ends up with someone trying to become ultra-specific.. for example, to improve jumping, why dont we just do jump squats at 30%? but why 30%, why not 0% since 0% is most specific? that reasoning goes nowhere.. the key is overload.. jump squats have been studied to be most effective at improving vertical jump @ loads of 30%, so we use 30%.. but this is to close a gap between explosive strength & max strength, which IS NOT the issue of this thread.
the issue in this thread is coming up with yet another alternative exercise which is supposed to compete with the basic lifts (squat/lunge/bss/calf raise/ghr).
my legs never wobble when im SLRVJ'n or DLRVJ'n, or sprinting for that matter.. so the increase stabilization argument of the shrimp seems pointless to me.. the increased 'difficulty' of the exercise seems completely pointless to me.. it's cool as an assistance exercise, or just to have fun with, but to replace the basic lifts with? IMO, no way..
lastly, let's not forget that sickenin wasn't even speaking about weighted shrimps like RJ, he was talking about bodyweight shrimps, which should clue you in to his ineffective ideas about training.. he's the same guy who would want to put christmas ornaments dangling from a barbell and forcefully twisted as you squat, so to improve your body's ability to COIL DA ACTIN/MYOSIN HELIX. people should read what he says carefully, and then use it to reinforce their belief in the time tested basics of simple progressive overload with the key exercises (squat, lunge/bss, ghr, calf raise, pullups, dips etc), reactive work (low level through high level), and some explosive work (oly variants or swings), and that's it.
people who are constantly looking for secrets, will never find the answer.
bbl dangling christmas ornaments and christmas lights from my barbell for my twisting lunges session & runup deadlifts :F